February 22, 2012

When is social media a tool of distraction?

Computer pioneer Alan Kay says computers in schools are largely a waste of time. What he says applies to the way many businesses and nonprofits try to use social networks.

Computers have been in schools for the last 30 years, but with few exceptions, they haven’t been used to their full potential.

Kay says the education system has squandered 30 years of technology in classrooms. He likens the modern factory educatory system to a monkey with a microscope. The monkey looks at its reflection in the microscope’s barrel but doesn’t look through the eyepiece — it utterly misses the point.

Computers have become tools of distraction, Kay said, instead of education. He singles out Guitar Hero as the best example of this — players get the fantasy of virtuoso guitar playing without learning a single note.

Now re-read the passage above, but replace the word “computers” with “social media,” and the word “schools” with “organizations.” If your organization has a Facebook page or a Twitter account or a blog, but no schedule for posting content, and no guidelines for what kind of content you’re posting, you’re like a monkey with a microscope. So take at least an hour, sit down with other people in the office, and answer a few key questions:

    Who are you trying to communicate with online?
    Where online are those people hanging out?
    What information do they want to get from you?
    How, and how often, do they want you to communicate with them?

Once you’ve answered those four questions, you’re on your way to using social media effectively.

For ROI, You Gotta Have an “I”

If you’re still tinkering around with social media to “see if it has any application” to your organization, you’re about 2 years behind already. The time for tinkering was 2008. But it’s never too late to start, so you need to get someone to help you put a plan in place now.

Chris Kieff nails it in a post today about the ROI of social media. Too many organizations assign an unpaid intern to their social media effort (zero investment) then complain that there’s no return on the investment.

In this case you get exactly what you pay for. Paying nothing for someone who understands the technology is foolish. It’s like hiring a mechanic to guide you to on the roads instead of a GPS.

If you haven’t begun using social media for your organization, what are you waiting for? I’m always willing to answer questions, no strings attached — and there are lots of other people out there who are answering the same kinds of questions.

The important thing is that you start making the investment, so you can start seeing the return.